BOOK 8 Chapter 4 I. Introduction: Critique of Current Practices in Physical Educatioon

Chapter 4

I. Introduction: Critique of Current Practices in Physical Education

1. The Problems with Athletic Education in Various Cities
   • Aristotle begins by critiquing how some cities focus excessively on athletic training, believing it to be beneficial for developing physical strength and courage.
   • However, he argues that these cities often end up damaging the bodies of children by emphasizing athleticism to the detriment of growth and form.
2. Criticism of Spartan Physical Education
   • Spartans are highlighted as an example of an extreme case. Although they avoid damaging children's physical growth, they produce individuals who are animal-like through severe physical exertions.
   • The Spartans assume that such harsh training leads to the development of courage, but Aristotle questions this assumption.
     • He argues that even if they aim for courage, their method is flawed and does not lead to true courage.

II. Misconceptions about Courage in Physical Training

1. Courage is Not Linked to Brutality
   • Aristotle critiques the idea that savagery or brute strength leads to courage, noting that the most savage animals or barbarian nations are not necessarily courageous.
     • Example: Some nations, like the Achaeans and Heniochi of the Black Sea, are known for their brutal practices like killing and cannibalism, but this does not equate to true courage.
   • Courage is more commonly found in those with tamer and nobler natures, resembling lion-like characteristics, which combine strength with a degree of nobility.
2. Spartans' Decline in Athletic and Military Superiority
   • Aristotle points out that while the Spartans were once dominant in both gymnastic and military contests, they have since fallen behind other cities.
   • Their initial superiority was not due to superior physical training, but because they trained when others did not.
     • Now that other cities have adopted similar or better training methods, the Spartans no longer hold their former advantage.

III. The Importance of Nobility in Physical Education

1. The Noble Should Lead, Not the Beastlike
   • Aristotle emphasizes that nobility should take precedence over mere physical savagery in education.
   • True courage comes from noble individuals, not from those who are merely animalistic or brutal, like wolves or other wild beasts.
     • Courageous acts stem from moral character and are driven by noble motivations rather than base instincts.
2. Overemphasis on Physical Exertion Leads to Vulgar Citizens
   • Societies that focus too much on physical education at the expense of other necessary skills or virtues produce vulgar citizens.
   • These individuals may be useful for certain tasks, such as military service, but are not well-rounded or capable of excelling in other aspects of political and civic life.
     • Aristotle argues that true education should aim to produce citizens capable of fulfilling multiple roles in society, not just one.

IV. The Role of Gymnastic in Education

1. Balanced Physical Training up to Puberty
   • Aristotle asserts that gymnastic training should play a role in education, but it must be approached carefully and with balance.
   • Up until puberty, physical exercises should be light, and children should not be subjected to harsh dietary restrictions or extreme exertion.
     • Overexertion at a young age can impede growth and damage the body, resulting in long-term harm rather than benefits.
2. Evidence from Olympic Games
   • Aristotle supports his argument by pointing to Olympic Games, where it is rare to find athletes who win both as boys and as men.
     • This, he argues, demonstrates that intense training during childhood can impair physical abilities later in life.
     • The compulsory exercises imposed on young athletes can have a negative impact on their overall capacity for athletic performance as adults.

V. The Appropriate Sequence of Education

1. Focusing on Other Subjects Post-Puberty
   • After reaching puberty, children should shift their focus from physical exertion to other subjects of learning for a period of three years.
   • This phase is essential for allowing the mind to develop and avoiding the pitfalls of focusing solely on the body during a critical time for intellectual growth.
2. Returning to Physical Training in Young Adulthood
   • Following this period of intellectual education, it is appropriate for young adults to return to more intense physical exertion and compulsory dieting.
   • However, Aristotle insists that mind and body should not be exerted at the same time. The reason being:
     • Physical exertion and mental exertion are naturally opposed to one another.
     • Focusing on one area (e.g., body) will naturally impede the development of the other (e.g., mind), which is why a balanced and sequential approach is necessary.

Extended Elaboration on Key Themes

1. Critique of Overemphasis on Physical Education

• Aristotle's critique of cities like Sparta highlights his holistic approach to education. Excessive focus on the physical aspects of education can lead to the production of unbalanced citizens.
  • In Sparta’s case, their focus on physical training and military excellence produced individuals who were strong but lacked the refinement necessary for other aspects of life, leading to their eventual decline.
  • Aristotle believes that courage and other virtues are moral qualities, not merely physical traits, and should be cultivated through balanced education.

2. The Role of Courage and Nobility in Education

• Aristotle draws a clear distinction between savagery and courage.
  • Courage, for him, is not about mere brute force or the ability to engage in violence. It is instead a noble quality that requires a moral disposition and a sense of purpose.
  • This belief ties back to Aristotle’s ethical theory, where virtues (including courage) are habituated through moral education, not purely through physical exertion.

3. The Balance Between Physical and Intellectual Development

• One of the key takeaways from Aristotle’s educational theory in this chapter is the necessity of balance.
  • He argues that focusing on one aspect of education—whether physical or intellectual—at the expense of the other leads to imbalanced individuals.
  • Physical education is important, but it must be moderate during childhood to avoid stunting growth. Similarly, while the mind should be developed after puberty, it must be complemented by renewed attention to physical conditioning as individuals approach adulthood.

4. Sequential Approach to Education

• Aristotle’s notion that education should be sequential—beginning with physical training, followed by intellectual development, and then returning to more intensive physical exertion—is an important aspect of his theory.
  • The idea that mind and body require separate phases of focus reflects Aristotle’s biological understanding of human nature.
  • His argument that physical and intellectual development are mutually exclusive in their intensity reinforces the need for a well-structured and thought-out educational curriculum that aligns with human development.

5. Civic Virtue and the Purpose of Education

• Ultimately, Aristotle’s critique of physical education is tied to his broader concern with civic virtue and the role of education in forming good citizens.
  • A well-rounded education that balances the physical and intellectual needs of the individual contributes to the formation of citizens who are capable of participating fully in civic life.
  • Citizens educated only in physical courage or military prowess are inadequate for the broader demands of political participation, where reason, judgment, and moral character are just as important as physical strength.

Conclusion: The Ideal Educational Approach

• In Chapter 4, Aristotle makes the case for a balanced and sequential approach to education, warning against the overemphasis on physical exertion to the detriment of the mind and moral character.
• He advocates for a period of lighter physical exercise during childhood, followed by a focus on intellectual development post-puberty, and finally returning to physical training in young adulthood.
• The goal of education is not just to produce strong bodies, but to create virtuous citizens who possess both moral courage and intellectual capacity, contributing to the greater good of the state.

Aristotle’s views on education, as reflected in this chapter, emphasize the importance of moderation, balance, and purpose, aligning both physical and intellectual training with the ultimate goal of human flourishing (eudaimonia).

---

Video Explanation

Video Explanation Not Yet Available.